Hot NewsThe Binding Of Isaac

Binding of Isaac AI Music Removed From Repentance+ GTA Run

Binding of Isaac AI music made with Suno is cut from Repentance+ on PC after a review bomb; console patches are pending and McMillen says he had no idea.

Key takeaways

  • The November 19 Repentance+ update brought the game to PS5, Xbox Series X/S and Switch 2 and added a crime-themed Daily Run on PC (Steam, Kotaku)
  • A Reddit user found Suno metadata in the run's music files, including one track tagged as created on October 30, 2026 (Kotaku, Dexerto)
  • Creator Edmund McMillen said he had no idea the Daily Run used generated music and that it would be removed (IGN, Kotaku)
  • Nicalis pushed a PC build listing removal of generated music files, and submitted the patch to Microsoft, Nintendo and Sony (Dexerto, IGN)
  • Recent Steam reviews for Repentance+ fell to between 8% and 10% positive, depending on when outlets checked (IGN, Kotaku, Dexerto)

The Binding of Isaac AI music controversy ended with a fast fix: Nicalis has removed the AI-generated tracks from the GTA-themed Daily Run in Repentance+ on PC, and has submitted the same patch to Microsoft, Nintendo and Sony. The music, made with the AI tool Suno, was found by players a day after the November 19 update, and creator Edmund McMillen said he had no idea it was in the game. The discovery set off a review bomb that left Repentance+ with "Overwhelmingly Negative" recent reviews on Steam.

The console versions still carry the music until their patches clear certification. Nicalis has not said who made the tracks or how they ended up in the build.

What happened with the Binding of Isaac AI music?

A special Daily Run added on November 19 shipped with music generated by Suno, and some of the files still carried Suno metadata. Players found it within a day, and the backlash reached McMillen by November 21.

The November 19 update was timed to land on the same day as the GTA 6 launch. Nicalis's Steam post called it "the most anticipated game launch of the year," a joke about Rockstar's release, and told players to try "today's Daily Run for a very special crime-packed surprise." Entering the seed V1CE BSMT starts a Vice City themed run with its own weapons and soundtrack, according to Kotaku and Dexerto.

Reddit user ShweetsStuff then posted a breakdown of that soundtrack. According to the post quoted by Kotaku, the run uses 14 music files: seven full songs plus intros, outros and other variants. Some files contained the comment "made with suno," and one track, drivingsong1.ogg, listed a creation date of October 30, 2026, less than three weeks before the update went live. Other files had the comment scrubbed, the poster said, because they were edited and exported later.

DateEventSource
October 30, 2026Creation date in the metadata of one Suno trackKotaku, Dexerto
November 19, 2026Repentance+ launches on consoles; PC update adds the crime-themed Daily RunSteam
November 20, 2026Reddit post shows Suno metadata in the run's music filesIGN
November 21, 2026McMillen responds on X; Nicalis ships a PC build that removes the musicKotaku, Dexerto

What did Edmund McMillen say about the AI music?

McMillen said the generated music was added without his knowledge and that he was working to get it removed. He posted on X on November 21: "Woke up to a sh*t show, obviously I had no idea it featured generated music in the daily run, looking into how that happened and getting it removed, stay tuned."

He did not say who was responsible. Dexerto reports that the run is credited to a modder known as Mr. Headcrab, and that the Reddit poster described that modder as strongly opposed to AI and unaware the music was generated. That claim comes from the Reddit post, not from Nicalis or McMillen.

The choice to launch next to GTA 6 came from Nicalis, McMillen told Eurogamer before the update, as quoted by Kotaku. He described it as the publisher's idea and "a fun experiment."

Has the AI music been removed from Repentance+?

Yes on PC, not yet on consoles. Within hours of McMillen's post, Nicalis announced a new build with "critical fixes," with "Removal of generated music files" first on the list, according to the post quoted by Dexerto.

Item in the Nicalis fix postStatus
Removal of generated music filesIncluded
Larynx + Car Battery bugFixed
PC patchLive
Xbox, Switch 2 and PlayStation patchSubmitted to Microsoft, Nintendo and Sony
NetcodeWork continuing

IGN notes that Nicalis gave no date for the console patches and offered no explanation for how the music got into the game, saying only that the team would keep working on new and old bugs. Players on PS5, Xbox Series X/S and Switch 2 who start the V1CE BSMT run before their patch arrives will still hear the original tracks.

Why was Repentance+ review bombed on Steam?

Players objected both to the AI music and to the lack of any AI disclosure on the Steam page. Valve requires developers to disclose AI-generated content on a store page, and IGN, Kotaku and Dexerto all report that the Repentance+ listing had none.

The review numbers moved quickly as the story spread. IGN reported that just 8% of recent reviews were positive. Kotaku put the figure at 9%, and Dexerto counted 10% positive out of 908 reviews from the past 30 days. All three describe the rating as "Overwhelmingly Negative."

Not every complaint is about AI. Dexerto notes that players also blamed the update for breaking mods and causing crashes, and Kotaku quotes reviews criticizing the number of fixes after a long wait. The November 19 Steam patch itself was mostly bug fixes: Nicalis listed fixes for Satan's stomp phase being skipped at exactly 600 damage, Curse of the Maze trapping players in the Ultra Secret Room, a crash when EOS failed to initialize, and constant controller rumble after opening the Mega Satan door, plus Item Descriptions that now show what an item flips to when Flip is held.

Which platforms is Binding of Isaac: Repentance+ on?

Repentance+ is on PC, and since November 19 it is also on PS5, Xbox Series X/S and Switch 2. It first arrived on PC in 2024 as an update to the long-running roguelike, according to Kotaku.

The console launch had been a long time coming. In a November 2025 Steam post, McMillen confirmed that Repentance+ would reach consoles, and in a July 2026 Q&A post he wrote that the full Isaac collection, including Repentance+, was headed to current consoles. In the same post he said the team was working on a small update that might release by the end of the year, and that he was deep into Mewgenics development and expected to work on its DLC for years. The November 19 update did arrive before the end of the year, but its first days have been dominated by the music issue. The AI music story now overshadows that launch, at least until the console patches go live.

For players, the practical points are simple. On PC, update the game and the Daily Run uses no generated music. On consoles, watch for the next Repentance+ patch, which Nicalis says is already with the platform holders. More coverage of the series is on the Binding of Isaac hub.

FAQ

What is the V1CE BSMT seed in Binding of Isaac?

It is the seed for the Vice City themed Daily Run added in the November 19, 2026 Repentance+ update. It has its own weapons and the soundtrack that turned out to be AI-generated.

Did Edmund McMillen use AI in Binding of Isaac?

McMillen said he had no idea the Daily Run used generated music and asked for it to be removed. Nicalis has not explained who added it.

Is the AI music still in Repentance+ on Switch 2?

For now, yes. The fix is live on PC and has been submitted to Nintendo, Sony and Microsoft, with no release date for those patches.

What AI tool made the Binding of Isaac music?

Metadata in several of the music files reads "made with suno," which points to the AI music generator Suno.

When did Repentance+ come out on PS5, Xbox and Switch 2?

Repentance+ launched on PS5, Xbox Series X/S and Switch 2 on November 19, 2026, the same day as GTA 6.

See our editorial policy.